Side Hustle Tips: Finding Great Deals at Garage Sales

Finding Great Deals at Garage Sales

It has been a while since I was in college. I’m in that weird age range where I’m sometimes considered an old millennial and other times a young member of generation X. I grew up in the dial-up generation where America Online (AOL) was king. My eBay account was created pre-2000 and I played online poker on sites such as Full Tilt and Party Poker. I was the in last graduating college class year before Facebook became mainstream around 2005 and my MySpace profile was all kinds of awesome (not really).

I played baseball in college, which was like a full time job. We had 6:30 am weight lifting sessions three times per week, a full day of classes, baseball practices or games, and then homework. It was a great experience that I wouldn’t trade for anything, but finding a normal college job was challenging. My parents helped pay my rent, but I was on my own for spending money. To my parent’s credit, they would have helped me more financially but I wanted to take care of myself as much as possible.

Therefore, I had to come up with a creative way to make extra spending money. The term side hustle wasn’t a common phrase back then, but that’s what I was looking to do instead of a typical job.

My College Side Hustles

One way I made a extra money was by playing online poker. I wasn’t the best poker player, though was decent enough to where I made a single $30 deposit and was able to pull out a few hundred dollars every couple months without ever having to make another deposit. My winnings were consistent in low dollar tournaments. Playing at higher stakes never ended up being profitable. Thankfully, I ended up making my final withdrawal the week before Full Tilt poker accounts were frozen. I narrowly missed having several hundred dollars inaccessible for months or years.

My other side hustle was reselling items on eBay. This is where I made most of my side hustle money in college. I hear a lot of people talking about retail arbitrage these days. Retail arbitrage is where an individual purchases an item at a low cost, usually from a retail store, and immediately checks a site like Amazon or eBay to determine if it can be resold at a higher price. This is basically what I did on eBay, except I did this before smartphones.

My niche was garage sales and dollar stores. Since I couldn’t immediately look up an item on my smartphone, I ended up wasting a lot of money on junk from garage sales that had no resale value. These losses became less frequent as I gained experience in my specialty areas.

Side Hustle Wins

Successes at the dollar store involved VHS tapes and computer games (I told you this was a long time ago). My best run ever was when I stumbled upon an old computer game called Total Annihilation. The game was selling for $1 at a dollar store called DEALS and was reselling for as much as $40 on eBay. I drove to every DEALS location in Southwest Missouri and ended up purchasing about 50 copies of the game. For someone who was used to being a broke college student, I lived well the next few months. I was able to take a break from Ramen noodles and ketchup spaghetti.

Most of my dollar store and garage sale purchases were smaller wins. VHS videos purchased for $1 would often resell for $8 to $10 on eBay. At garage sales, I usually did well with items such as video games, board games, VHS/DVDs, athletic equipment, and sports memorabilia. I once came across a copy of a rare Super Nintendo game called Mega Man X3. The game was purchased for $5 and resold on eBay for $200.

I will still occasionally get the family up early on a Saturday morning and go to garage sales. My wife buys books for her classroom, my three year old buys a few toys, and I keep an eye out for items that I can resell on eBay.

The eBay market is much more competitive these days. eBay fees are higher, the market is more saturated with large companies, and free shipping has almost become the standard. The margins for retail arbitrage will continue to shrink as companies wise up or more re-sellers enter the market. However, people will always have garage sales to quickly get rid of their junk. With a little experience and patience you will come across the right items to make money. Below are a few tips to make decent money by reselling items found at garage sales on eBay.

Garage Sale Tips

Pick a few specialty areas and get to know them well

There is an advantage to picking a few specialty areas and knowing those areas really well. For example, my main specialty area was video games. I got to the point where I knew the rough price range for most any game. Sports games typically didn’t sell very well, while role playing games would usually turn a profit. Even with smartphones, having specialty areas will allow you to move quickly through garage sales and identify the items that are more valuable.

The one exception is I always pay closer attention to new or sealed items even if they are not in my specialty area. I have stumbled upon a few garage sales where unopened wedding or baby shower gifts are available for cheap. Electronics, cooking accessories, and toys in the original packaging can do really well in the resale market.

Seek out Neighborhood Garage Sales

Finding great deals at garage sales is all about volume. You need to be able to move quickly from house to house. Once you have experience, as soon as you walk up to a garage sale you’ll know if it is a dud or potential gold mine.

Going to a site like Craigslist and searching for key words such as “subdivision”, “annual”, or “neighborhood” can quickly point you in the direction of the larger sales in the area. I have found that upper middle class neighborhoods are the most profitable. Low income areas have more junk while high income areas have fewer sales as I’m assuming they donate more to charity to avoid the hassle of a garage sale.

Show up Early!

Most anything decent at a garage sale will be gone before 10 am, if not earlier. There will be others out there looking to resell items so it will be important to beat them to it. You may also be able to catch sellers the night before setting up their garage sale. Getting there the night before or too early in the morning can be disrespectful, so I tend to wait until the official starting time to show up. More aggressive garage sale veterans may disagree with my thoughts on not showing up before the official starting time.

Focus on Smaller Items for Simpler Shipping

Shipping can be a huge pain if you run a smaller operation. Now days I tend to focus on purchasing items that can fit into an large yellow envelope. For example, DVDs and  Video Games are easy to prepare and ship. Don’t get me wrong, if I come across a larger item where the potential profit margin is significant, I will buy it. However, the margin has to be worth it to go through the extra hassle of shipping a larger item. Many eBay vendors are moving to free shipping, so it will be important to keep shipping and packaging costs to a minimum. Items such as DVDs and video games are usually light enough to be shipped first class and you can package them in a basic bubble wrap envelope that can be bought in bulk.

Utilize Your Smartphone at Garage Sales

This goes without saying, but take advantage of your smartphone when looking for items to resell. I usually have the eBay app up with the proper filters (e.g., completed items) as I browse garage sales. For new or used items with a bar code, you may be able to scan using Amazon or other apps for a quick price check. Most people don’t seem to care if you are looking up items on your phone, though I’ve found it does make the negotiation process more challenging.

I also think it’s rude if you are spending too much time hovering over items searching for every little thing on your smartphone. This goes back to the point of having a specialty area that allows you to quickly identify items that you can quickly search on your smartphone. Don’t be too obvious, but also use it as a tool to keep you from making poor purchase decisions.

Make an Offer

The majority of the time garage sale hosts are willing to take less than the original price. Don’t waste your time negotiating 50 cent items down to 25 cents. However, negotiating a $20 item down to $10 can make a big difference. People also seem to be more willing to lower the price if you are purchasing multiple items. Negotiation is a great skill to have in many aspects of life. Going to garage sales is a great way to practice this skill. Also, I’m not going to lie, my three year old seems to help with negotiating better deals.


There are opportunities to make decent side hustle money reselling items on eBay. This is especially true if you are in a decent sized metropolitan area. The market is more competitive today than 15 years ago. However, individuals still get rid of valuable items at garage sales all the time. If I could be successful before smartphones, you certainly can with the assistance of your iPhone. Get out there and find your Mega Man X3 or Total Anihilations.

If you have questions please leave a comment and I’ll respond as soon as possible.

Thanks for reading!



  1. I just started getting into garage sale flipping. It started about a week ago when picking up a free desk and the guy wanted everything in the room gone. I ended up selling a personal sauna for $200 and some other things for a total of around $500-600. Plus it’s a lot of fun.

    Since ebay is rather competitive and i’m still learning. Would you recommend small household appliances as a local speciality item? I’m referring to like toasters, clothes irons, etc. Also should i have a different speciality item on ebay?

    1. Best of luck! I’ve always had a lot of fun with flipping on eBay. I haven’t done it for a while and I know that eBay is much more competitive than it used to be. The listings have to look much more polished. I think anything can work as a specialty item category as long as there is a decent margin and you know your buyers. For eBay I would make sure the items are not too big or heavy since shipping can really add up. Thanks for reading and good luck!

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.